This is going to be filled with spoilers, so don’t click below if you haven’t seen the movie yet.
Where to begin? I’m just gonna launch into it and hope my thoughts make sense.
Grievous. He is taken out far too easily. Trained in the ways of the Jedi? Not too well trained, apparently. This is even more true for people who have seen the Clone Wars cartoons, but I won’t cite them cause that’s being a bit unfair. But really, without the context Grievous is never seen as a real threat. I’d go more into how he served almost no purpose at all in the movie, but let’s move on.
Padme’s death during labor. As I recall from Return of the Jedi, Luke asks Leia if she remembers anything about her mother, her real mother, and Leia says she does and gives him some vague memories. But nope, according to Lucas, who decided to ignore this, her memories were false.
Vader’s yell. No explanation needed on this one.
The totally random comment about Qui-Gon. This one is just pathetic. On another note, I don’t even know why Qui-Gon was in the prequels. In The Empire Strikes Back, Obi-Wan tells Luke to seek out Yoda on Dagobah, the Jedi Master that taught him. Yoda should have been Obi-Wan’s master in the prequels. Another example of Lucas forgetting what was in his original movies.
Luke being sent to live with his family on Tatooine. Someone explain to me how this is a good idea.
“Hide the children from Vader we must.”
“Let’s send Luke to be with his family.”
“Smart idea this is. Jedi master you should be.”
Anakin’s turn to the Dark Side. Or to put it more accurately, his decision to join the Dark Side. You don’t just decide to join the bad guys. A Jedi needs to taste the power, be seduced, and fall. One moment it’s “Don’t kill Palpatine!”, the next he chops off Mace Windu’s hand, then he says with lament, “What have I done?” and finally it’s, “Yes, my master?”
His decision to join was based almost purely on the desire to learn the “trick” to save his wife. He isn’t even evil yet at the point where he joins Palpatine. Palpatine then commands him to slaughter the Jedi to become stronger, and he does it. Once again, not cause he’s evil, but because he wants to learn a trick. This is not compelling storytelling.
Obi-Wan beats Anakin because he holds the higher ground. What kind of bull is this? It’s such a lame reason for Obi-Wan to beat Anakin that Lucas has Obi-Wan actually explain to the audience. “It’s over, Anakin. I hold the higher ground.” Well, gosh, if that’s all it takes to defeat another Jedi, why didn’t he just stand on the table in the room where they were fighting earlier? Hey, there’s a ramp, go stand on top.
“Hey Obi-Wan, tell us again how you defeated that Sith Lord.”
“I was standing two feet higher than him.”
“Oh.”
“Yeah.”
“I’m just gonna walk around on stilts from now on.”
The final confrontation between Obi-Wan and Anakin should be the epitome of Dark Side vs. Light Side. Light should triumph over Dark because of some flaw in the Dark Side, not because the Light Side holds some lame tactical advantage.
Yes, I’m being extra picky on some points. But anyone who defends this stuff is either a misguided fan or not a fan at all. This stuff does matter when you’re writing a story that must accomodate predefined material.
All of this is focused mostly on ROTS itself. I won’t go into stuff that I don’t like about the prequels, like inconsistencies with the clones, Yoda and the Emperor moving super fast and using lightsabers (Think about any kung fu master, like Pai-Mei from Kill Bill, Chow Yun-Fat from Crouching Tiger, and even Neo at the very end of the first Matrix), the prophecy about Anakin and making him super powerful, recurring characters throughout all six movies and spanning 20 years (The droids, Chewbacca, Boba Fett…), and the random twirling and spinning during lightsaber duels.
I’m done ranting. I hope I got it all out.